Montpelier City Hall, a tan brick building with a clock tower, on Main Street in downtown Montpelier

Montpelier hires Burlington Deputy Chief Jonathan Young to lead its police department

Montpelier City Hall on Main Street. The city manager's office announced the hire Monday. Photo: John Phelan / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Montpelier has hired Burlington Deputy Police Chief Jonathan Young to run its police department, ending a search that began after the city’s chief and deputy chief both left for Northfield in May. Young starts Monday, Jan. 4, 2027, according to the city’s announcement issued Monday by City Manager Kelly McNicholas Kury.

He inherits a department that is budgeted for 17 sworn officers and 10 dispatchers but has spent most of the year short-handed. For a capital city that also hosts the Legislature from January to May, the timing matters: Young takes over two days before lawmakers return to the State House.

“I look forward to this new role in the capital city,” Young said in the release. “My goals are always to leave people feeling safer, calmer, and more valued after every interaction with the police.”

Who Montpelier hired

Young is a U.S. Marine Corps veteran with 26 years in law enforcement, the city said. His résumé includes time as a federal air marshal with the Transportation Security Administration’s Boston Field Office. He holds an associate degree in criminal justice and a master’s degree in executive leadership from Champlain College, where he now teaches criminal justice as an adjunct professor.

Most of his career has been in Burlington. The Times Argus reported that he joined the Burlington Police Department in 1998, retired in 2021 to manage field services at Vermont Gas Systems, and returned in June 2025 as one of two deputy chiefs. That puts him in the leadership of the state’s largest city department during the same stretch Burlington named Anthony Geraci as its new chief.

McNicholas Kury pointed to that Vermont background. “His proven success in Vermont law enforcement and familiarity with many of the same public safety issues facing our city today will allow him to smoothly onboard with the Montpelier Police Department,” she said in the release.

Sixteen applicants, four finalists

The city ran the search with JW Consulting, a law enforcement recruiting firm. A position profile was written in August, the job was open through September and candidates were vetted in October. Sixteen people applied, four of them from Vermont, the city said.

Four finalists met a seven-member community panel drawn from mental health services, homelessness outreach, local transit, the City Council, the business community, the police union and the fire department. They also sat before a law enforcement panel with members from the Capitol Police, Vermont State Police and Montpelier police, had one-on-one interviews with the city manager and met department staff.

The City Council approved about $40,000 for the national search on July 8, VTDigger reported. The Bridge reported the job carries a salary of $130,000 to $150,000, according to the city’s recruitment brochure.

A department rebuilding its ranks

The vacancy opened in May when Chief Eric Nordenson left to lead the Northfield Police Department and Deputy Chief Kevin Moulton went with him. Two more Montpelier officers followed to Northfield. VTDigger reported the departures left the department with 11 officers and six vacancies at one point, and the city weighed whether it could keep round-the-clock patrol coverage. Detective Sgt. Jeffrey Pearson has served as interim chief since July 6.

The picture has improved but not fully. McNicholas Kury told The Bridge the department now has 13 officers, including two recent hires still in field training, and runs on a $4.37 million operating budget. She listed overtime, retention and succession planning as ongoing problems, with several officers eligible to retire in the next four to five years.

Those numbers will shape Young’s first months. Filling four sworn positions in a tight statewide hiring market, and planning for retirements behind them, will land on his desk alongside the city’s budget work for the fiscal year that begins July 1. Montpelier’s annual budget goes to voters on Town Meeting Day, which falls on March 2, 2027; our guide to how Town Meeting works explains that process.

Pearson remains interim chief until Young is sworn in on Jan. 4. More coverage of the capital region is in our Local News section.

Add Vermont Daily News as a preferred source on Google (opens in a new tab)